yrieithydd: Celtic cross with circle and knotwork pattern (Cross)
“A wandering Aramean was my ancestor …”
Thus begins what could be seen as an early Jewish “creed”. Not statements of abstract belief but a story. I do this thing now because of the story of God interacting with my people. In Deuteronomy 26, that thing is bring the first fruits of the harvest to God. We do this thing now – share bread and wine – because “on the night when he was betrayed, Jesus took bread…”

The stories we tell are important because they shape the way we see the world. I love watching NCIS but I’m deeply unsure about one of the underlying stories it tells – which is that it’s ok for the goodies to shoot the baddies, although there’s an underlying backstory for Gibbs which sometimes emerges to ask questions about that assumption.

We see the importance of stories in the invasion of Ukraine – Володимир Зеленський (Volodymyr Zelenskyy), the Ukrainian president said in a speech to the people of Russian “The Ukraine in your news and Ukraine in reality are two completely different countries. The most important difference is ours is real. You are being told that we are Nazis”. He continues with stories about the fight against Nazism, both national and personal, in the past.

Our stories tend to portray us as the goodies and the other side as the baddies. But the problem is the other side have stories too and they see themselves as the goodies and us as the baddies – see how the West and NATO are portrayed as the aggressors by the Russians. I saw a tweet a couple of days ago pointing to a C4 interview with a support of Putin who justified the deaths in Ukraine by reference to the killing of civilians by the US and UK in Iraq in 2003, in Belgrade, in Afghanistan. And sadly the Patriarch of Moscow is justifying the invasion as against evil forces. And throughout history the Christian church has justified wars.

Lent is a chance for us to go back to our stories and ask questions. Jesus after his baptism goes out into the desert and is tempted by stories – “If you are the Son of God….” And Jesus answers with stories “it is written…”.

What will we do to deepen our engagement with the stories this Lent? I have bought a Lent book which engages actions of the Easter story and hope to be disciplined about reading it.

Prayer for Ukraine
The Fellowship of Reconciliation which founded by a handshake between a German Lutheran and an English Quaker on the eve of the first world war and continues as an international movement of people who commit themselves to active nonviolence as a way of life and as a means of personal, social, economic and political transformation and of which I am a trustee is holding Friday evening vigils for which you can register via this link

(Written for the St Nick's Leicester weekly update - it's not the piece I was planning on when I agreed to write it a couple of weeks ago when I was thinking about revisiting my Pianos and prayer analogy formed in arguing about spiritual disciplines with I think a Sydney Anglican (though I thought it was about Lent so I might be wrong about who the shipmate was too), but world events changed my mind)
yrieithydd: Celtic cross with the knot work in red, orange, yellow, green, blue and purple as with the Pride flag (Rainbow Cross)
I have just sent the following to the Bishop of London and others.

I'm writing to you to express my disappointment in how you have failed to support Jarel in the current media storm surrounding him. My social media (facebook and twitter) feeds yesterday had a number of posts yesterday which offered a critique of the hype surrounding Captain Tom. It is noticeable that the one which has resulted in its author being pilloried is the one by the queer black man. Admittedly, it was probably the most stark and blunt of the comments I saw, but the reaction it has provoked has in fact proved the point Jarel was making.

There are, it seems to me, at least three levels to the story here.
  • The genuine response of many people to Captain Tom and the desire to help the NHS.
  • The way the story has played in the media and with the politicians (who haven't been funding the NHS or paying staff well for years). It is a nice feel good story which has been used to divert criticism from the failings in the handling of the pandemic. Where is the outrage over £2.75million a day being spent on consultants by Track and Trace?
  • And the wider larger narrative of British nationalism and the legacy of empire. Because he, like most of his generation, was a war veteran, the WWII narrative came into it. But that narrative is often used to obscure questions of injustice now:  we can't be the bad guys because we defeated Hitler. Yet you can have a newspaper which tells people off for not wearing a poppy call judges "the enemy of the people" for holding the government to account.


Some people may have seen Jarel's tweet who were in the first group and were genuinely hurt by it coming at a time when their grief was raw and possibly Jarel's timing was off with that. But when can we have this debate and ask these questions?
 
Systemic racism is part of the situation we are in and the Church of England has shown some signs of wanting to get to grips with that systemic racism and yet, here its instinct is apparently to back down and appease the right wing media. Speaking the truth to power is not popular. 

As a pacifist, I've wanted to say something about the everyday militarism of calling a man who left the army immediately after the end of WWII "Captain Tom" but was aware that people would take that as a slur on the man and not engage with the wider issue. Jarel took the decision to risk making the comment about the wider narrative. 

The reaction has been predictable and I've been saddened by lack of support from the diocese. What part of the Digital Charter/Social Media Guidelines did Jarel's tweet break? He's been on the receiving end of abuse but he is the one being investigated. 

I should say that I know Jarel slightly in person having overlapped in Cardiff a bit and met at events such as the service outside Westminster Abbey while the military establishment met inside the Abbey to give thanks for the service of the submariners on the Trident subs. I hope that his voice will not be silenced.

Profile

yrieithydd

May 2023

S M T W T F S
 1234 56
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 19th, 2025 08:21 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios