yrieithydd: (Wyddor)
[This post is mainly aimed at those living in Wales as we're the ones who can vote, but others might be interested in the underlying issues. I'd also be interested in opinions on the objectivity of this post. I'm not cutting it as it's a public post and I might tweet it.]

Hopefully, you're all aware of the referendum in Wales on 3rd March (tomorrow as I write). But as there no group applied for the status of official no campaign, there have not been TV broadcasts or mailshots for either yes or no campaigns which may well have reduced awareness of the issues.

This is a quick email to encourage you all to consider the issues and to go out and vote. Polls open at 7am and close at 10pm on Thursday 3rd March. In recent weeks, we have seen people in the Middle East and North Africa demonstrating on the streets, at times at risk to their lives, for democracy. We are lucky in living in a democracy with free and fair elections and referendums, and I believe we have a duty to engage with the democratic process by voting.

I have a very strong opinion about how I am going to vote, but I hope in this email to give you information on the issues so you can make up your own mind.

The National Assembly for Wales was created in 1999 after the yes vote in the devolution Referendum in September 1997. At that time, it had no primary law-making powers. In 2006, a second Government of Wales Act was passed which gave the Assembly law making powers in a few areas and the ability to apply to Westminster to gain law making powers in the other devolved areas after the May 2007 Assembly elections. To gain more law making powers, the Assembly had to propose a Legislative Competence Order (LCO). In the LCO the Assembly set out what powers it was asking for and went through a process of consultation and committee scrutiny in the Assembly and then in both houses in Westminster and if all houses agreed it received Royal Assent. Once an LCO has received Royal Assent, the Assembly can then introduce a Measure to make a new law in that area. This then goes through a process of public consultation and committee scrutiny in the Assembly before being passed by the Assembly and then receiving Royal Assent.

Got that? I don't blame you if you haven't. I know the system because I worked for a political party at the Assembly and I can assure you that it is convoluted and long-winded.

Under this current system, more and more powers will be devolved to the Assembly area by area as LCOs are passed. The 2006 Government of Wales Act, however, set out a way to speed this process up. If the people of Wales vote yes in a Referendum on this issue, then the Assembly gains primary law making powers in all devolved areas wholesale. This means that rather than taking at least a year to pass an LCO and then another year to pass a Measure, the Assembly will be able to start the Measure straightaway.

The most extreme example of the problem with the current system is the area of Housing. In 2007, the Labour, Plaid and LibDem manifestos contained a promise to suspend the 'right-to-buy' (for tenants of council housing) in areas of high housing need. These three parties won 47 of the 60 seats in the Assembly. You might therefore thing that this would be an easy matter for the Assembly to legislate upon. However, because of the LCO system, nearly 4 years later the Measure is still to be passed, although it is nearly there. It has taken this long because it took 3 years to gain an LCO giving the Assembly the powers to do this. I believe that the House of Parliament are supposed to judge whether it is appropriate that Wales should have the powers it has asked for, however in the case of the Housing LCOs (two because we had to return to the drawing board once), it was blocked because MPs (especially Conservative ones) did not approve of the laws the Assembly might have passed, although it was the power to completely abolish the right-to-buy which was the real sticking point, which is not the intention in the first instance but was included in the LCO for completeness sake.

I promised to be fair and set out the issues, so I've just checked True Wales' website and their reasons for voting no. Despite having been founded to campaign for a no vote in this Referendum, True Wales did not apply for official campaign status meaning there have been no officially recognised campaigns and so no TV broadcasts or mailshots. Some people have suggested that this is because True Wales want a low turnout so that they can claim that the result is not legitimate though they have denied this.

Having looked at their reasons for voting no, they do not appear to me to engage with the (admittedly technical) issue that the referendum is about. They criticise the record of the Assembly and suggest that voting yes is a slippery slope to Independence. Although there are those in the Yes campaign who are in favour of Independence, that is not the matter at issue here and there would have to be a Referendum on that specific issue.

For full balance, the website for the Yes Campaign is also available

I hope I have managed to be reasonably objective and clear in setting out the issues here.
yrieithydd: (Wyddor)

Take the Who Should You Vote For? Wales quiz

Plaid Cymru72
Liberal Democrat36
UK Independence-28

You expected: Plaid

Your recommendation: Plaid Cymru

Click here for more details about these results

Only think I'm slightly surprised by is that I more definitely not Tory than not UKIP. I think it also shows something about how left wing Labour are!

yrieithydd: (Wyddor)

Help yrieithydd and get your own badge!
(The Livejournal Electioniser was made by robhu)

I'm intrigued as to who the Tory is. The person I might have guessed is a mutual friend with the person I got this meme from and she has no Tories appearing.
yrieithydd: (Wyddor)
I was slightly surprised to see that the picture on the front of the Electoral Commission's Guidance for candidates and agents: Local government elections in Wales, 1 May 2008 featured a grey-haired white bloke and no-one else. Maybe that is the stereotype of councillors (and or agents) but surely that's something that such guidance should seek to challenge rather than enhance.

Thus I went to the Electoral Commission's website and found that I could download the document and the equivalent documents for England and London as well as for Wales (which is also available in Welsh I'm glad to see). Now the English and London versions have younger blokes on them, but they're still blokes. Given the under-representation of women in politics I think this is a very bad thing™.
yrieithydd: (Wyddor)
I've just been reading Stephen Cottrell's book From the abundance of the heart: Catholic Evangelism for all Christians which is a good read.

I was amused this even though to be visited by a Plaid member who described a visit to a member in an area where the branch is not really functioning despite having members on the books. He'd asked this lady why she wasn't more involved and she responded because of having two young children, she couldn't do evening meetings. He suggested maybe a garden party for socialising and discussing nursery education. This is exactly one of the strategies suggested in Stephen Cottrell's book.


Apr. 7th, 2004 08:12 pm
I feel polluted. I got home this evening and checked the post pile and found a letter addressed to me (in a nice pale yellow) envelope. I opened it, unsuspecting, to find that it was from Michael Howard MP.

Amusingly, it contains (along with waffle about how bad Labour are) a form for postal voting to 'make it easier to vote'. This amuses me because I live closer to the polling station than I do to a post box, I think. At least, there can be very little difference in distance (they're in opposite directions).

It was bad enough getting a letter from the local (tory) MP on my 18th birthday, but the leader of the Tory party??????



July 2017



RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 20th, 2017 05:30 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios